Why you should care about RTW for direct-care workers

According to US News and World Report, it is estimated that in 2013, roughly 3.3 million Americans called a nursing home their place of residence.  For these millions of residents, there must also be millions of people to care for them. 

Productive modified duty for nursing staff

Nursing homes are rated on various aspects of their operations by Medicare.  Nursing homes are rated on health inspections, staffing, and other quality measures.  One element of staffing criteria that is measured is the number of staffing hours per resident.  A facility reports the number of hours of care on average provided to each resident, each day, by its nursing staff.  It is important that RNs and LPNs, for example, are providing care to residents as opposed to “non-care” hours.  This is important when considering modified duty opportunities for long and short term care facilities.

When considering modified duty options for health care staff, a great place to start is their job descriptions.  What aspects of their jobs fit, or can be modified to fit, within their work abilities?  Consider other areas or departments for opportunities.  While there may be some initial resistance, some of the duties that other health care employees perform may also yield modified duty opportunities.  An example of this would include having an RN perform duties that an LPN could do.  Another great source of modified duty suggestions is to ask the injured worker what they believe they could do.  This will provide suggestions, but also foster support of the return to work process.

Keeping injured workers at work doesn’t just help your workers’ compensation insurance costs

When an employee is injured, the repercussions are felt throughout an organization and the community.  Maintaining a staff of qualified and skilled employees is a challenge in any industry, but is particular evident in the health care field.  According to one study, the cost of turnover in the direct-care industry was found to be 25% of an employee’s total annual compensation.¹ The Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates in 2003 that costs associated with turnover in this industry ranged between $4,200-5,200.

            Direct costs:

·          separation

·         vacancy, replacement, training and injuries

Indirect costs:

·         lost productivity

·         reduced service quality

·         lost clients revenues due to lost existing and potential clients

·         impact on the culture, morale, facility reputation and service quality

Service delivery level costs:

·         Consumers/Clients

o   quality of care

o   quality of life

o   care hours not provided

·         Employees

o   increased work injuries (doing more with less)

o   increased physical and emotional stress

o   reduced working conditions may lead to higher turnover

Suggested resources

There are many resources available to employers who wish to offer modified duty to one of their injured workers.  The Job Accommodation Network (JAN) is a great resource for ideas and modification suggestions.  We previously wrote about it in this post.   Our website also has a variety of tools to help, in addition to lists of suggestions for health care employees who are given restrictions as the result of a work injury.

You can also check out the studies and resources referenced in this post by clicking here.

1.  Seavey, D. (Oct., 2004).  The cost of frontline turnover in long-term care. Washington, D.C.:  Better Jobs Better Care.

Complimentary Webinar: Using Not-for-Profit Organizations as a RTW option

Are you or your clients interested in learning about a new and innovative RTW solution?  Sign up for a complimentary webinar being offered by Eastern Alliance Insurance Group's Return to Wellness Specialist, Sarah Tayts. 

WHO:     This presentation is open to all EAIG agency partners and EAIG clients.  Please feel free to forward this post via email to anyone you believe would benefit from attending this presentation.  You can do this by clicking on the envelope icon located at the bottom of this post, or simply copy/paste the URL to this post into a separate email.


WHAT:     The presentation will highlight how to strategically use NFPs to solve even your most challenging RTW situations, as well as address the most common questions regarding the process. 

WHEN:     Wednesday, December 4, 2013 @ 10 am EST

HOW:     Register for the webinar by clicking here and completing a basic registration form.  For more information on how to get the most out of the GoTo Webinar session, you can click here to view a brief PowerPoint tutorial.               

In the past, this presentation has been very well attended, so be sure to register now to reserve your spot!

Guest post! Physical Therapy may assist in recovery from a musculoskeletal injury, and depression, in the injured worker by Dr. Joseph Brence, DPT

As you know, we’re always interested in hearing others’ perspectives regarding the rehabilitation of an injured worker. We’re excited to share this guest post written by Joseph Brence, DPT, COMT, DAC.  Dr. Joseph Brence is a physical therapist practicing in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.  When he is not busy treating patients, he is involved in several, large clinical research projects.  He has a large interest in the brain's involvement in the pain experience as well as the neurophysiological effects of manual therapy techniques. You can read more from Dr. Brence at www.forwardthinkingpt.com

Physical Therapy may assist in recovery from a musculoskeletal injury, and depression, in the injured worker
Joseph Brence, DPT, COMT, DAC

Work-related injuries affect almost 500,000 individuals annually in the United States.  Over half of these cases are related to sprains, strains and other musculoskeletal pathology.  In addition, musculoskeletal injuries are the leading cause for work-related disability and lost productivity, and estimated direct and indirect costs range from 45 – 215 billion dollars.

Work-related injuries can lead to the development of chronic pain as well as changes in societal status and psychological variables such as depression. Research has suggested that one out of every three individuals who suffer from chronic pain also suffer from depression.  Research has also suggested that elevated levels of depression are associated with an increased risk for a poor response to Physical Therapy and are associated with elevated levels of pain and disability.  A recently published article examined the effects of Physical Therapy on depressive symptoms in individuals with work-related musculoskeletal injuries.

The authors in this prospective cohort study recruited patients who were between the ages of 18 and 65; had sustained a work-related, musculoskeletal neck or back injury (3-12 weeks since onset); were not currently working; and were receiving benefits from Worker’s Compensation.   The participants also had to have clinically relevant levels of depression (measured on a Beck Depression Inventory of 14 or higher) and had to state that they were not being treated for depression throughout their course of Physical Therapy (often the case in Workers Compensation).  The participants completed a course of seven weeks of Physical Therapy treatment interventions.

The outcomes of this study demonstrated that depressive symptoms resolved in 40% of patients who entered into a Physical Therapy program, following a work-related accident. This outcome is not unusual because of the neurological and hormonal changes that we know to occur with exercise.  The authors further reported that a reduction in depressive symptoms was related to a decrease in pain and disability at the one-year follow-up, which improved the likelihood for return to work.   For those who did not get better, it appears that combined elevated levels of depression and pain catastrophizing thoughts (ex. The pain is killing me) pre-treatment, predicted persistence of depressive symptoms post-treatment.  

So what does this mean?

These findings indicate that Physical Therapy can have a profound effect in decreasing depressive symptoms in a subgroup of individuals.  The authors go as far as suggesting that in certain instances, we may want to include a reduction in depression as a realistic and important goal of treatment.  Psychosocial variables, such as this, have been correlated to long-term disability and can often restrict an individuals ability to recover from a musculoskeletal injury (thus decreasing the likelihood for return to work).  Despite the notion that many in Workers Compensation field want to steer away from the assessment of these variables, I suspect they are important prognostic indicators for recovery and we should encourage early screening, detection and intervention.  In the end, we interact with the complex "human" and acknowledging the influence of biological, psychological and social variables, will only better enhance recovery and return to work. 
 

Dunning KK, Davis KG, et al. Costs by industry and diagnosis among musculoskeletal claims in state workers compensation system: 1999-2004. Am J of Indust Med. 2010: 53; 276-284.

Wideman TH, Scott W, et al. Recovery from depressive symptoms over the course of physical therapy: a prospective cohort study of individuals with work-related orthopaedic injuries and symptoms of depression. JOSPT 2012: 42; 957-968.

Kroenke K, Spitzer RL, et al. The Patient Health Questionnaire-2: Validity of a 2 item depression screener. Medical Care. 2003: 41; 1284-1294.

The "rules" of WC aren't a secret -- really anyone can find them...

Workers’ compensation has existed in the United States for over 100 years.  Unarguably, things have changed since 1911.  One acronym says it all:  EDI.  Don’t worry, this isn’t a post about EDI at all – we’re trying to gain a following here, not see how quickly people “x” out of their browsers.

Every year we hear of a few states who are taking a crack at this reform or that amendment.  These changes are typically a fusion of neighboring states’ systems, but with a twist!  Each state’s laws address workers’ compensation it a bit differently but whether you’re in Texas or PA, there are some similarities that, amazingly, people still don’t know about. So, here are a few common things about WC that I wish more people knew.

Medical providers:  If you want to get paid you need to submit your bill with medical records.

Would you pay a bill if you had no idea what it was for?  Despite they average person's usual philanthropic tendencies, I’d bet not.  Why would you expect an insurance carrier to pay for something when they don’t know what they’re paying for? 

Here’s what happens.  The carrier gets a medical bill or invoice without records.  The carrier denies it and requests that it be resubmitted with medical records.  Maybe the billing company is a separate entity and can’t just print out the records.  The billing company then has to request the records from the provider, who then sends them to the billing company who sends them, hopefully, with the appropriate bill, back to the carrier.  This could take a few weeks.  Suppose that in the interim, the provider identifies this as an account with a balance on it and they send a second notice to the injured worker, causing all sorts of outrage and frustration, when all the while letters and requests are crossing in the mail. 

An avoidable mess is the most frustrating mess!

Modified duty reduces claim costs

It’s as if this is a big secret!?  I’ve always said that for every attorney billboard along the major highways that we see, I wish there was one explaining why modified duty makes sense – if done properly.  I bet if you asked people what happens to their rates when they file a homeowner’s or auto damage claim the overwhelming majority of people would say, “My rates go up.”  It’s so prevalent NBC’s Today Show website has an article on this topic from just 6 days ago! The more a claim costs, the more it impacts your policy (in most cases).  WC coverage is no different.  Modified duty is one of the most effective ways to reduce indemnity (wage) loss costs on your policy.  Carriers don’t make this stuff up!

The “rules” of WC aren’t a secret – really anyone can find them.

Employees say the darndest things...

A few months ago, I wrote about the importance of communicating your RTW program.  Maybe some of our loyal blog-followers have taken steps to communicate their modified duty or RTW policy.  Maybe not.  No matter which group you find yourself in, here’s a little experiment to help you gauge just how much your employees know, or don’t know, about RTW.

That’s right an experiment.  Please don’t feel as if you must limit yourself to workers’ compensation and return to work programs.  Expand the scope of this very non-scientific study I’m about to propose, and see what comes back. 

Drum roll, please.

Ask your employees what type of benefits they have available to them.

Ta-da!  Voila!  Profound, isn’t it??

Here’s my point – the results will likely surprise you.  I envision the responses reminiscent of the interviews on “Kids Say the Darndest Things”.  Ask anyone open-ended questions, and you just never know what responses you’re going to get.  I’d be willing to bet that modified duty and workers’ compensation aren’t on the top of the list.  That’s a problem, particularly if you have a RTW program that you’ve put a lot of effort into.

So, what can employers do?

Obviously the first step is to communicate the message to your employees.  This message should be clear, consistent and simple.  Like most things in life, the fewer words the better.  There are many suggestions on how to do this (newsletters, posters, payroll stuffers, wallet cards, annual compensation statements, etc.) As an aside, we’ve created a lot of these things already.

You’ll probably feel like I do when I talk about modified duty or return to work (or, as we say, wellness) – you feel like you’ve communicated your message a thousand times.  The amazing thing is that there are still many people who haven’t heard it.  Maybe they were in the restroom, or maybe they were on vacation or out sick, or sadly, maybe they were present but don’t remember the message.  The point is, not everyone has heard it, and it’s worth saying again, and again, and again, until your employees can communicate the message back to you – or until they start mimicking (in jest) your catchy saying you’ve come up with as part of your communication strategy.  Spoof or no spoof, you’ll know they’ve got the message!